The Cambrian-Ordovician siliciclastic sequence from the Tandilia System, Argentina  

DANIEL G. POIRÉ, LUIS A. SPALLETTI AND ANALÍA DEL VALLE

The Tandilia System is situated in the Buenos Aires province, between latitudes 36° 30' - 38° 10' South and longitudes 57° 30'- 61° West (Fig. 1). Its maximum length is 350 km in the NW SE direction. The hills are composed of an igneous metamorphic basement and a Precambrian and Lower Palaeozoic sedimentary cover.

The sedimentary Precambrian succession exposes in the north-western part, around Olavarría and Barker-San Manuel region (Fig 1), while the Lower Palaeozoic crops out in a western belt of the range and mainly towards the south-east (Balcarce-Mar del Plata area, Fig. 1).

These deposits líe on a crystalline basement named Buenos Aires Complex by Marchese and Di Paola (1974), which is older than 2,000 Ma and it is composed of granitoids, migmatites, ectinites, milonites, anfibolites and basic dykes.  

Many authors have contributed to the knowledge of the Tandilia sedimentary succession (cf. Iñiguez et al., 1989). In this synthesis the framework proposed by Dalla Salda and Iñiguez (1979) and modified by Poiré (1987; 1993) for the Precambrian units is followed. In the same way, the sequencial setting composed of three Riphean sequences, a Vendían-Rephean sequence and a final Ordovician one (Iñiguez etal.,1989) is also accepted.

From the lithostratigraphic point of view (Table 1) the Precambrian sedimentary successions comprise a) the Villa Mónica Formation (Poiré, 1993) and its equivalent Las Aguilas Formation (Zalba, 1978), b) the Cerro Largo Formation (Poiré, 1993), and c) the Loma Negra Formation (Borrello,1966), all of these constituents of the Sierras Bayas Group (Dalla Salda and Iñiguez,1979; Poiré, 1993), and d) the Cerro Negro Formation (Iñigue2 and Zalba, 1974) and its equivalent Las Aguilas Formation (Zalba,1978). The Lower Palaeozoic succession is known as the Balcarce Formation (Dalla Salda and Iñiguez, 1979).

These lithostratigraphic units were grouped by Spalletti et al. (1996) finto five depositional sequences (Table 1): the Tofoletti (I), Malegni (II) and Villa Fortabat (II)) sequences are Riphean, the La Providencia sequence (IV) is Vendían-Riphean and the Batán sequence (V) is Cambrian-Ordovician. On the other hand, Andreis and Zalba (1998) for the Chillar-San Manuel named these sequences as A1, A2, B, C y D, respectively.

Between the crystalline basement and the sedimentary cover, arkosic and quartz-kaolinitic saprolites indícate palaeowethering surfaces (Zalba et al.,1992). A peculiar event is the presente of diamictites between the crystalline basement and the Balcarce Formation reported in the El Volcán Hill (Spalletti and del Valle,1984).

Being all these units unfossiliferous they carry biogenic sedimentary structures (trace fossils and stromatolites) as the only evidente of biocoenosis in the Precambrian and Lower Palaeozoic seas of this region. Precambrian stromatolites are located in the Villa Mónica Formation, where they are arranged in biostromes and bioherms dated between 800 and 900 Ma (Poiré, 1987; 1993). In the Precambrian units, trace fossils are scarce and show a poor ichnodiversity. Palaeophycus isp. and Didymaulichnus isp. have been described in the Cerro Largo Formation (Poiré et al., 1984), while Helminthopsis isp. and probable medusa resting traces have been found in the Loma Negra Formation. Skolithos isp. has recently been registered in the Lower part of the Cerro Negro Formation.  

Upper Precambrian sedimentary rocks  

The Upper Precambrian sedimentary cover of Tandilia in Sierras Bayas (close to Olavarría) is a 167 m thick succession (Sierras Bayas Group) composed of three depositional sequences separated by regional unconformities (Poiré,1987;1993).

The oldest depositional (Tofoletti) sequence (52 m thick) shows two sedimentary facies associations: a) quartz-arkosic arenites to the base and b) dolostones and shales to the top. The first one is composed of shallow marine siliciclastic rocks (conglomerates, quartz and arkosic sandstones, diamictites and shales), and the second is characterised by shallow marine stromatolitic dolostones and shales. This sequence has been dated in 800-900 Ma.

The second depositional (Malegni) sequence (75 m thick) consists of a basal succession composed of chert breccia, fine-stratified glauconitic shales and fine-grained sandstones, followed by cross-bedded quartz arenites which are in turn covered by fine-grained siliciclastic rocks (siltstones and claystones). This sequence represents a shallowing upward succession from sutidal nearshore to intertidal flat deposits. An age between 700-800 Ma has been defined from Rb/Sr dating (Bonhomme and Cingolani, 1980).

 

The younger depositional (Villa Fortabat) sequence is a 40 m thick unit composed almost exclusively of red and black micritic limestones, originated by suspension fall-out in open marine ramp and lagoonal environments.

On top of the Sierras Bayas Group a regional unconformity is recognised (Barrio el al, 1991). This surface has been related with a sea-level drop, meteoric dissolution-of the carboriatic sediments, and consequent development of a karstic surface on which residual clays and brecciated chert accumulated.

The Vendian Cerro Negro Formation (La Providencia Depositional Sequence) appears on top of the above described unconformity. It is a more than 100 m thick unit characterised by claystones and heterolithic fine-grained sandstone -claystone interbeds, mainly formed in upper to lower intertidal flats.  

Lower Paleozoic sedimentary rocks  

The Lower Palaeozoic siliciclastic succession is known as Balcarce Formation (Batán Depositional Sequence). This unit has been studied by del Valle (1987a). It is overlaying the crystalline basement or the former sedimentary units (Cerro Negro Formation, Las Agudas Formation, Sierra del Volcán Diamictites and Punta Mogotes Formation).

The Balcarce Formation (100 m. thick) is composed of white quartz sandstones and granule sandstones with subordinated levels of mudstones (kaolinitic-rich clays) and quartz conglomerates. The geometry of the sandstone beds is sheet-like; most sedimentary bodies are bounded by convex-upward surfaces, though some wide channel-like features are also present. Planar and tangential cross-stratifications are the dominant structures within sandstone bedsets, and large-scale sigmoidal bodies are frequent in most sections. Sheet-like and lenticular sandstone-mudstone interbeds are commonly intercalated among sandstone storeys. Trace fossils are abundant at the top surface of the sandstone member in sandstone-mudstone interbeds. The quarries all around Batán and Chapadmalal towns allow to depict the stratigraphic architecture of the Balcarce Formation. Based on their contrasting geometry; two main groups of layers can be defined in this siliciclastic succession: one group is characterised by a sub-horizontal stacking pattern (aggradational geometry) and the other shows very well developed depositional clinoforms (progradational geometry). The observatiónal facies of the Balcarce Formation as well as the inferred transport mechanisms and type of deposits are usted on Table 2.

Diagnostic criteria to recognise tidal processes in fair weather and storm events have been summarised on Table 3. Tidal processes are inferred from the features of cross-bedded sandstone facies (bars) and heterolithic (wavy and lenticular) facies (swales). Large to medium scale laterally persistent bodies of cross-bedded sandstones, exhibit rhythmic lateral variations in the thickness of foresets and in clay content due to spring and neap tide alternation. Clay drapes covering foresets and other sedimentation surfaces, herringbone cross-bedding, opposite palaeocurrent trends in successive sedimentary bodies and reactivation surfaces also suggest tidal deposition. The migration and accretion of bidimensional sand bars seem to be controlled by highly asymmetrical time-velocity tidal currents. Subordinated, high-energy storm episodes are suggested by hummocky cross-bedded sandstones, sheet conglomerates armouring previous tidal sand bodies, and heavy mineral concentrations in the wavy sandstone laminae of heterolithic facies.

An epicontinental shallow marine open shelf is inferred for the Cambrian-Early Ordovician in the Tandilia basin. Most sedimentary facies were developed in the nearshore and inner shelf environments of a fide-dominated and storm influenced platform.

Trace fossils  

On the account referentes about the Precambrian trace fossils of Tandilia are scarce. Palaeophycus isp. and Didymaulichnus isp. have been descxibed in the Cerro Largo Formation by Poiré etal. (1984), while Helminthopsis isp. and probable medusa resting traces in the Loma Negra Foxmation. Skolithos isp. have recently been registered in the lower part of the Cerro Negro Formation.

On the other hand, the rich variety and the abundante of trace fossils in the Lower Palaeozoic Balcarce Formation have been mentioned by many authors: The first findings have been made by Hauthal (1896) and Nágera (1919, 1926), but it was Borrello (1966) who studied and described a wide trace fossil collection taken from different localities of Tandilia. Aceñolaza (1978) revised the subject a gave a modernised focus to the study of trace fossils from Tandilia, together with other Lower Palaeozoic ichnofossils of Argentina. Later records are due to Alfaro (1981) in the La Numancia-Licenciado Matienzo area, Regalia and Herrera (1981) in the San Manuel arca, Zalba et al. (1982) in the Las Aguilas Hill, Cingolani et al. (1985) in the Corral Hill, del Valle (1987a y b) in different localities from the Balcarce-Mar del Plata area, Poiré and del Valle (1994,1996) in the coastal outcrops of Mar del Plata, and Poiré (1998) in the Chillar area.

The Balcarce Formation shows a great quantity of trace fossfs and a much higher ichnodiversity. After revising the already published material thoroughly and taking into account the recent discoveries made by the authors, the following up-dated list of trace fossils is presented: Ancorichnus ancorichnus, Arthrophycus alleghanensis, Arthrophycus isp., Bergaueria isp., Cochlichnus isp., Conostichuis isp., Cruziana furcifera, Cruziana isp., Daedalus labeckei, Didymaulichnus lyelli, Didymaulichnus isp., Diplichnites isp., Diplocraterion isp., Herradurichnur scagliai, ?Monocreterion isp., Monomorphichnus isp., Palaeophycus alternatus, Palaeophycus tubularis, Palaeophycus isp., Phycodes aff. pedum, Phycodes isp., Plagiogmus isp., Planolites isp., Rusophycus isp., Scolicia isp. and Teichichnus isp. (Fig. 2).  

The age of Balcarce Formation  

The precise age of the Balcarce Formation is difficult to determine. Through radiometric dating (600Ma) and the presence of acritarchs the underlying Cerro Negro Formation has been dated in the Vendian (Cingolani et al., 1991). The upper limit of the Balcarce Formation is sustained by an intrusive diabase body dated around 450 and 498 Ma (Rapela et al., 1974). Consequently the unfossiliferous Balcarce Formation would be assigned to the lapse Cambrian-Ordovician. During the seventies and eighties Cruziana has been considered a useful biostratigraphy indicator (cf Seilacher,1970; Crimes,1975). Based on this concepts, the presence of Cruziana furcifera has been one of the most substantial elements to accept an Arenigian age for the Balcarce Formation. Nevertheless, recent contribution by Marwood and Pemberton (1990) seriously questioned the validity of Cruziana in biostratigraphy. On the other hand the appearance of Plagiogmus isp. would strongly indicate a Cambrian age (Glaessner,1969; Crimes,1975).

According to the available stratigraphic and geochronologic information the Balcarce Formation can be either considered Cambrian and/or Ordovician. Future and more detailed ichnological studies and their comparison with other unfossiliferous quarzites rich in trace fossils from this Gondwana region, as the Lower Palaeozoic successions from South Africa and Malvinas Islands, could result to establish a more accurate age of such a peculiar unit of the Tandilia System

 

.

References  

Aceñolaza, F. G. 1978. El Paleozoico inferior de Argentina según sus trazas fósiles. Ameghiniana 15(1-2):15-64, Buenos Aires.

Alfaro, M.B. 1981. Estudio geológico de la zona comprendida por las Hojas La Numancia, Licenciado Matienzo y Estancia San Antonio, en las Sierras Septentrionales de la provincia de Buenos Aires. V Reunión Científica Informativa, Resúmenes :9, Comisión de Investigaciones Científicas (C.IC.) de la provincia de Buenos Aires, La Plata.

Andreis, R.R and Zalba, P.E 1998. El basamento cristalino y eventos transgresivos y regresivos en las sucesiones silicoclásticas proterozoicas y eopaleozoícas aflorantes entre Chillar y San Manuel, Sierras Septentrionales, Buenos Aires, Argentina. VII Reunión Argentina de Sedimentología, Actas de Resúmenes :102-103, Salta.

Barrio, C. Poiré, D.G. and Iñiguez M. 1991. El contacto entre la Formación Loma Negra (Grupo Sierras Bayas) y la Formación Cerro Negro, un ejemplo de paleokarst, Olavarría, provincia de Buenos Aires. Asociación Geológica Argentina Revista 46: 69-76. Buenos Aires.

Bonhomme, M. and Cingolani, C. 1980. Mineralogía y geocronología Rb-Sr y K-Ar de fracciones finas de la "Formación  La Tinta", provincia de Buenos Aires. Asociación Geológica Argentina Revista 35: 519-538. Buenos Aires.

Borrello, A. V. 1966. Paleontografía Bonaerense. Fascículo V. Trazas, restos tubiformes y cuerpos fósiles problemáticos de la Formación La Tinta, Sierras Septentrionales, provincia de Buenos Aires. Comisión de Investigaciones Científica., Provincia de Buenos Aires, 42 Pp., La Plata.

Cingolani, C.A., Varela, R. and Aceñolaza, F. G. 1985. Caracteres geológicos e icnolcígicos del Cerro del Corral (partido de Necochea), provincia de Buenos Aires. Primeras Jornadas Geológicas Bonaerenses, Actas :891-908, Tandil.

Cingolani C.; Rauscher, R.. and Bonhomme, M. 1991. Grupo La Tinta (Precámbrico y Paleozoico inferior) provincia de Buenos Aires, República Argentina. Nuevos datos geócroriológicos y micropaleontológícos en las sedimentitas de Villa Cacique, partido de Juarez. Revista técnica de Ypfb 12(2): 177-191, Santa Cruz. 

Crimes, T.P,1975. The estratigriphical significante of trace fossils. En R.W Frey, The Study og trace fossils  Springex­Verlag, :109-130, New Yorr.

Dalla Salda, L and Iñiguez, A.M., 1979. La Tinta, Precámbrico y Paleozoico de Buenos Aires. VII Congreso Geológico Argentino Actas 1: 539-550. Neuquén.

Del Valle, A., 1986. Presencia de conglomerados mantiformes en el techo de secuencias psamíticas de la Formación Balcarce, Buenos Aires, Argentina. I Reunión Argentina de Sedimentología, Resúmenes Expandidos: 193-19G. La Plata.

Del Valle, A., 1987a. Sedimentología de lo Formación Balcarce en el sector oriental de Tandilia. PhD Thesís, Facultad de Ciencias Naturales y Museo, Universidad Nacional de La Plata 491: 279 pp. La Plata (unpublished). 

Del Valle, A., 1987b. Nuevas trazas fósiles en la Formación Balcarce, Paleozoico inferior de las Sierras Septentrionales. Su significado creonológico y ambiental. Revista del Museo de La Plata, nueva serie, Sección Paleontología 9: 19-41. La Plata.

Del Valle, A. 1990. Paleogeografía de la cuenca de depositación de la formación Balcarce (Ordovícico inferior), Tandilia, Argentina. III Reunión Argentina de Sedimentología Actas: 102-108. San Juan.

Di Paola, E.C. and Marchese, H.G. 1974. Relación entre la Tectosedimentación, litología y mineralogía de arcillas del Complejo Buenos Aires y la Formación La Tinta (provincia de Buenos Aires). Revista de la Asociación Argentina de Mineralogía, Petrología y Sedimentología 5(3-4):45-58, Buenos Aires.

Glaessner, M.F., 1969. Trace fossils from the Precambrian and basal Cambrian. Lethaia 2: 369-393, Oslo.

Hauthal, R. 1896. Contribución al estudio de la geología de la provincia de Buenos Aires, I. Las Sierras entre Cabo Corrientes e Hinojo. Revista del Museo de la Plata 7:477-489, La Plata.

Iñiguez, A.M. and Zalba, PE., 1974. Nuevo nivel de arcilitas en la zona de Cerro Negro, partido de Olavarría, provincia de Buenos Aires. LEMIT, Provincia de Buenos Aires Serie II(264):93-100.

Iñiguez, A.,M.; Del Valle, A., Poiré, D.G., Spalleti, L. and Zalba, P ,1989. Cuenca Precámbrico / Paleozoica inferior de Tandilia, Provincia de Buenos Aires. En Chebli, G. y Spalletti, L. (Eds.) Cuencas Sedimentarias Argentinas. Serie Correlación Geológica 6 (Universidad Nacional de Tucumán): 245 - 2G3. S. M. de Tucumán. Marwood, J.PA. and S.G. Pemberton, 1990. Stratigraphic significante of Cruziana: New data concerning thc Cambrian-Ordovician ichnostratigraphic paradigm. Geology 18(8):729-732.

Nágera, J.J. 1919. La Sierra Baya (Prov. de Buenos Aires). Estudio geológico y económico. Anales del Ministerio de Agricultura, Sección Geología, Mineralogía y Minería XIV(1):1-66, La Plata.

Nágera, J.J. 1926. Note precambriennes argentines (Bonaerense). Congreso Geologie International, Bélgica 1922, 13 Session, 3:1651-1655, Liegé.

Poiré, D.G:, 7987. Mineralogía y sedimentología de la Formación Sierras Bayas en el núcleo septentrional de las sierras homónimas, Partido de Olavarría, Provincia de Buenos Aires. PhD Thesis l Facultad de Ciencias Naturales y Museo, Universidad Nacional de La Plata: 494: 271 pp. La Plata (unnpublished).

Poiré, D.G., 1993. Estratigrafía del Precámbrico sedimentario de Olavarría, Sierras Bayas, provincia de Buenos Aires, Argentina. XII Congreso Geológico Argentino y II Congreso Exploración de Hidrocarburos Actas II: 1-11. Mendoza.

Poiré, D.G., 1998. Estructuras sedimentarias orgánicas en sedimentitas gruesas del Paleozoico de Chillar, Tandilia, Argentina. 5tas.  Jornadas Geológicas y Geofísicas Bonaerenses t:9-18, Mar del Plata.

Poiré, D.G. and Del Valle, A. 1994. Depositional facies and trace fossils of a Cambrian/Ordovician shelf bar deposit, Balcarce Formación, Cabo Corrientes, Mar del Plata, Argentina. 14th International Sedimentological Congress S5-6, Recife.

Poiré, D.G. and Del Valle, A., 1996. Trazas fósiles en barras submareales de la Formación Balcarce (Ordovicico), Cabo Corrientes,-Mar del Plata, Argentina. Asociación Paleontológica Argentina, Publicación Especial 4:89-102, Buenos Aires.

Poiré, D.G., Del Valle, A. and Regalía, G. M. 1984. Trazas fósiles en cuarcitas de la Formación Sierras Bayas (Precámbrico) y su comparación con las de la Formación Balcarce (Cambro-Ordovícico), Sierras Septentrionales de la provincia de Buenos Aires. IX Congreso Geológico Argentino, Actas 4:249-266, San Carlos de Bariloche.

Rapela, C.W, L. Dalla Salda, L. and Cingolani, C., 1974. Un intrusivo básico ordovícico en la "Formación La Tinta" (Sa. De los Barrientos, Buenos Aires). Revista de la Asociación Geológica Argentina 29(3):319-331, Buenos Aires. 

Regalía, G.M. and Herrera, H. 1981. Phycodes aff. pedum (traza fósil) en estratos cuarcíticos de San Manuel, Sierras Septentrionales de la provincia de Buenos Aires. Revista de la Asociación Geológica Argentina 34(3):257-261, Buenos Aires.

Seilacher, A. 1970. Cruziana stratigraphy of "non-fossiliferous" Palaeozoic sandstones. En T.P Crimes y J.C. Harper (Eds.), Trace Fossils :447-476, Seel House Press, Liverpool.

Spalletti, L.A 1987. Características y significado sedimentológico de las formas, cuerpos y estructuras originadas por agentes Fluidos en sustratos incoherentes. Revista del Museo de La Plata, Nueva Serie, Sección Geológica 10:16-69, La Plata.

Spalletti, L.A. and Del Valle, A. 1984. Las diamictitas del sector oriental de Tandília: caracteres sedimentológicos y origen. Revista de la Asociación Geológica Argentina 39(3-4):188-206, Buenos Aires.

Spalletti, L.A. and Poiré, D.G. 2000. Secuencias sitcoclásticas y carbonáticas del Precámbrico y Paleozoico inferior del Sistema de Tandilia, Argentina. II Congreso Latinoamericano de Sedimentología and VII Reunión Argentina de Sedimentología, Guía de Campo, 39 pp, Mar del Plata.

Spalletti, L.A., Poiré, Isla, F. and Zárate, M., 1996. Litoral atlántico bonaerense y Sistema de Tandilia. VI Reunión Argentina de Sedimentología, Guía de Excursión Geológica, 15 pp., Bahía Blanca.

Rapella, C., Dalla Salda L. and Cingolani, C., 1974. Un intrusivo básico ordovícico en la Formación La Tinta (Sierra de los Barrientos, Prov. de Buenos Aires). Asociación Geológica Argentina Revista 29: 319-331. Buenos Aires. 

Zalba, PE., 1978. Estudio Geológico-mineralógico de los yacimientos de arcillas de la Lona de Barker, Partido de Juárez Pcia. de Buenos Aires y .ru importaneza económica. Tesis Doctoral 362. Facultad de Ciencias Naturales, Universidad Nacional de I,a Plata, 175 pp., La Plata (unpublish).

Zalba, P. E., Andreis, R.R. and Lorenzo, F. C. 1982. Consideraciones estratigráficas y paleoambientales de la secuencia banal eopaleozoica en la Cuchilla de las Águilas, Barker, Argentina. V Congreso Latinoamericano de Geología 2:389-409, Buenos Aires.

Zalba, P, Poiré, D.G., Andreis, R. and Iñiguez, A.M., 1992. Precambrian paleoweathering records and paleosurfaces of Tandita System, Buenos Aires Province, Argentina. En Schmitt, J. & Gall, Q. (Eds.) Mineralogical and Geotermical Records of Paleoweathering. ENSMP Memoires des Sciences de la Terre 18: 153-161.